DraftHistory.com

Quarterbacks Selected in the 1st Round and Those Taken Later Who Outperformed Them

By Chris Malumphy

1st Round Quarterbacks and QBs Taken Later Who Outperformed Them
(Based on Pro-Football-Reference.com Career Value)
YearNameTeamPlayerCareer
Value		Outperformers
(V=Career Value, P=Player)
2010Sam BradfordRams144  
2010Tim TebowBroncos2512Colt McCoy V-14 P-85
2011Cam NewtonPanthers1111  
2011Jake LockerTitans815Andy Dalton V-84 P-35; Colin Kaepernick V-45 P-36; Tyrod Taylor V-41 P-180; Christian Ponder V-22 P-12; Blaine Gabbert V-16 P-10
2011Blaine GabbertJaguars1016Andy Dalton V-84 P-35; Colin Kaepernick V-45 P-36; Tyrod Taylor V-41 P-180; Christian Ponder V-22 P-12
2011Christian PonderVikings1222Andy Dalton V-84 P-35; Colin Kaepernick V-45 P-36; Tyrod Taylor V-41 P-180
2012Andrew LuckColts171Russell Wilson V-120 P-75; Ryan Tannehill V-76 P-8; Kirk Cousins V-73 P-102
2012Robert Griffin IIIRedskins237Russell Wilson V-120 P-75; Ryan Tannehill V-76 P-8; Kirk Cousins V-73 P-102
2012Ryan TannehillDolphins876Russell Wilson V-120 P-75
2012Brandon WeedenBrowns2214Russell Wilson V-120 P-75; Kirk Cousins V-73 P-102; Nick Foles V-31 P-88
2013EJ ManuelBills1610Geno Smith V-15 P-39; Mike Glennon V-13 P-73
2014Blake BortlesJaguars344Derek Carr V-66 P-36
2014Johnny ManzielBrowns225Derek Carr V-66 P-36; Teddy Bridgewater V-38 P-32; Jimmy Garoppolo V-27 P-62; Logan Thomas V-7 P-120
2014Teddy BridgewaterVikings3238Derek Carr V-66 P-36
2015Jameis WinstonBuccaneers154  
2015Marcus MariotaTitans245  
2016Jared GoffRams149Dak Prescott V-61 P-135
2016Carson WentzEagles245Dak Prescott V-61 P-135
2016Paxton LynchBroncos262Dak Prescott V-61 P-135; Jacoby Brissett V-23 P-91; Jeff Driskel V-6 P-207; Cody Kessler V-5 P-93; Brandon Allen V-4 P-201
2017Mitchell TrubiskyBears233Patrick Mahomes V-54 P-10; Deshaun Watson V-52 P-12
2017Patrick MahomesChiefs1054  
2017Deshaun WatsonTexans1252  
2018Baker MayfieldBrowns131Lamar Jackson V-48 P-32; Josh Allen V-35 P-7
2018Sam DarnoldJets315Lamar Jackson V-48 P-32; Josh Allen V-35 P-7
2018Josh AllenBills735Lamar Jackson V-48 P-32
2018Josh RosenCardinals103Lamar Jackson V-48 P-32; Mason Rudolph V-4 P-76
2018Lamar JacksonRavens3248  
2019Kyler MurrayCardinals130  
2019Daniel JonesGiants617  
2019Dwayne HaskinsRedskins153Gardner Minshew II V-16 P-178; Drew Lock V-8 P-42
2020Joe BurrowBengals17Justin Herbert V-13 P-6
2020Tua TagovailoaDolphins55Justin Herbert V-13 P-6
2020Justin HerbertChargers613  
2020Jordan LovePackers260Jalen Hurts V-4 P-53; Ben DiNucci V-1 P-231; Jake Luton V-1 P-189